Singing Actors, Acting Singers

   As we all know, poor me is on the drama/movie shortage for the next 2 years. Iggi is slowly coming to me, so tomorrow I will probably pass out, but I can count on no more than 2 movies per year from that ungrateful JJY, so I started to watch musicals. Korean ones, to be exact. And… damn I love it.
And while watching one version of Jekyll & Hyde, I started to have some strange creeps. I was watching and I realised that I know the actor singing so fabulously. Jo Seungwu. I was in complete shock, He sang great in 70 70 Go!, but it was the movie, so, you know, studio recording can make everything. I can even sound like Aretha Franklin (maybe not, ok), but this was some live performance. I knew he was a nice actor (Jina-sshi, kamsahamnida^^), but somehow his singing abilities didn’t strike me that much in this musical movie. The stage is different. The stage shows everything. If an actor is weak – it will strip him of any delusions (sure, some can just make it up by different aspects), if an actor is good – everything will just stop, and there will be only him/her on the stage and you. Not a person from the audience. You.
   I’m far from my point of this post. Actors in Korea sing. Better or less good (ah, I am so euphemistic, back to my normal self – they suck!), but they can sing, or at least hold a note. I was slightly biased towards singing during FM (fanmeetings), but KNG changed my mind. He doesn’t have any spectacular voice in singing, he sings higher than his speaking voice, but clearly and not “airy”, I hate airy voices. Plus, he doesn’t make an idiot out of himself when he sings on the stage. Yes, I watched what I could, even from 2006, when he had his hand in the bandage. So… OK, without any inappropriate adjectives.
Godss, I lost my point again, damn you, Namgil-nim!
My point is – when you sing, sing well. I don’t buy an excuse about the fatigue, I don’t buy any excuse about “not being the singer”. What a cosmic bullsh*t. If you record an album, or a single not as a part of the OST, you are moving toward singer-zone. Sorry. So do it well.

   Omo, I am bashing Keunsuk again. Yes, yes I am. Because watching all those actors on the stage, and later, their performances on the stage not as the part of the musical, but just a song in some show (ah, Yoon Dohyun’s Love Letter was such a great show, not only because Dohyun-sshi has a fabulous voice himself, but all those performances. He himself also starred in a musical called Hedwig and the Angry Inch), made me realize that he’s in fact an idol, not even a singer. He has a great voice, but he can’t do nothing much with that voice – live. If the song is not his, he fails, he can’t hit the notes right.

The thing is, JKS said he’s not a singer. That would be great, and I would understand the less great performances on the stage, but… He’s not an actor either. I mean, no he starred in few movies and dramas, but be frank, they are not masterpieces. Beethoven Virus is maybe the best, but because of Kim Myungmin. And for that drama JKS sang his the only good song. But what he has been doing lately? Fanmeetings that consist of… singing? Hell, he’s been singing for the entire year. I’m fed up with his vanity, with his conceitedness and with his “oh, it’s just a joke” attitude. So a note to all: forget it.
   Some singers appear in dramas/movies – see my post on Dead Carp and The Table^^. They may have tons of charm and charisma, but forgive me, I had to take off my glasses and I didn’t see it. I’m blind as a bat without them, and I wouldn’t even notice Namgil-nim or Jaeyoung-nim on the street. Unless of course I did bump upon them and cause a multiple fractures. Then, maybe… Maybe I’m biased, yes, I’m biased, but I see no singer that is a great actor. It works the other way round – actors sometimes are great singers.
Proof: Jo Seungwu. Damn, I was taken aback.
First: his live musical, and he’s the Jekyll/Hyde, song – This is the moment:
The same song sung on Korean Musical Awards:
Jo Seungwu as Hedwig:
70 70 Go! OST:
The same song (This is The Moment)  in my recent love Hong-sshi’s version:
His other song, I gave the link to it, but didn’t give the actual performance:
And time for a Spring Awakening, that stirred up the whole Korea about the topics that it covers.
Totally Fucked:
The Mirror Blue Night song (sings Kim Muyeol, the musical heartthrob, he was awarded for his performance in this musical):
Advertisements

About ethlenn

Just usual suspect
This entry was posted in Hong Kwangho, korean, korean music, musical. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Singing Actors, Acting Singers

  1. Aili says:

    How about female singers who have gone to the big screen? They have pulled off better than the males ones, no?

  2. Ethlenn says:

    Not everyone, but in general yes. It's because they can be more emotional in the end, and they do not think that much about ruining the face.

    I'm not talking about the now idols, like SNSD, After School etc. They all suck!

  3. Ethlenn says:

    I haven't been to soompi for ages. I'm kinda scared of that place nowadays^^
    But it's good to know:)

  4. Suzanne says:

    haha yeah I know. I've stopped going there for a long time myself, because most of the posts are on pop idols I don't know and don't care to know. 🙂

  5. Ethlenn says:

    Most of the post there are written by hormonaly unstable girls… I got a beating from them, and I don't want to repeat it.
    This is why I hang around here and on D-A.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s